(Eastern Shore, Va.) – The Eastern Shore Health District currently has 13 confirmed cases of COVID-19. The District was unable to identify specific causes related to travel or close contact with a known infected individual for some of these cases, confirming community transmission of the virus. The health department continues to conduct surveillance and investigation of any future potential cases.
“We need to place less focus on the overall number of cases and operate under the assumption there are many more infected individuals than have been identified through testing,” states Jon Richardson, Chief Operating Officer. The COVID-19 virus is circulating in all our communities right now, and the number of infected people is increasing rapidly. It spreads person to person. Every time we leave our home we run an increasing risk of COVID-19 infection. It is imperative that we obey Governor Northam’s STAY AT HOME Order. We must comply with the Governor’s Order to protect ourselves, our families, and our neighbors. Lives are at stake. Stay home, stay safe, stop the spread!
Dave Gay says
Wouldn’t it make sense to identify those who have COVID-19 so others can stay away from them? Seems like we are operating blind by assuming everyone has been infected. Using the current system we are still seeing people getting infected. So how effective is the current process. Love to hear other comments.
Paul Plante says
Of course it makes all the sense in the world what you are saying, David Gay.
It happens to be what the law as written in the Commonwealth actually provides for, if we lived in a nation governed by rule of law as opposed to the blundering incompetence and outright stupidity we are witnessing instead, which can only make sense to a fool, an idiot, or a complete moron.
12VAC5-90-107. Quarantine.
A. Application.
The commissioner, in his sole discretion, may invoke the provisions of Article 3.02 (§ 32.1-48.05 et seq.) of Chapter 2 of Title 32.1 of the Code of Virginia and may order a complete or modified quarantine of any individual or individuals upon a determination that:
1. Such individual or individuals are known to have been exposed to or are reasonably suspected to have been exposed to a communicable disease of public health threat;
2. Exceptional circumstances render the procedures of Article 3.01 (§ 32.1-48.01 et seq.) of Chapter 2 of Title 32.1 of the Code of Virginia to be insufficient, or the individual or individuals have failed or refused to comply voluntarily with the control measures directed by the commissioner in response to a communicable disease of public health threat; and
3. Quarantine is the necessary means to contain a communicable disease of public health threat to which an individual or individuals have been or may have been exposed and thus may become infected.
The commissioner, in his sole discretion, may also order the quarantine of an affected area if, in addition to the above, the Governor has declared a state of emergency for such affected area of the Commonwealth.
B. Documentation.
For quarantine for a communicable disease of public health threat, information about the infection or suspected infection; the individual, individuals, and/or affected area; and the nature or suspected nature of the exposure shall be duly recorded by the local health department, in consultation with the Office of Epidemiology.
This information shall be sufficient to enable documenting a record of findings and enable the commissioner to prepare a written order of quarantine, including the information required in § 32.1-48.09 of the Code of Virginia.
In addition, sufficient information on individuals shall be maintained by the local health department to enable appropriate follow-up of individuals for health status evaluation and treatment as well as compliance with the order of quarantine.
The commissioner shall ensure that the protected health information of any individual or individuals subject to the order of quarantine is disclosed only in compliance with state and federal law.
C. Means of quarantine.
The local health department shall assess the situation, and in consultation with the Office of Epidemiology, shall recommend to the commissioner the least restrictive means of quarantine that effectively protects unexposed and susceptible individuals.
The place of quarantine selected shall allow the most freedom of movement and communication with family members and other contacts without allowing disease transmission to others.
The commissioner, in his sole discretion, may order the quarantined individual or individuals to remain in their residences, to remain in another place where they are present, or to report to a place or places designated by the commissioner for the duration of their quarantine.
The commissioner’s order of quarantine shall be for a duration consistent with the known incubation period of the communicable disease of public health threat or, if the incubation period is unknown or uncertain, for a period anticipated as being consistent with the incubation period for other similar infectious agents.
In the situation where an area is under quarantine, the duration of quarantine shall take into account the transmission characteristics and known or suspected incubation period.
D. Delivery.
The local health department shall deliver the order of quarantine, or ensure its delivery by an appropriate party such as a law-enforcement officer or health department employee, to the affected individual or individuals in person to the extent practicable.
If, in the opinion of the commissioner, the scope of the notification would exceed the capacity of the local health department to ensure notification in a timely manner, then print, radio, television, Internet, and/or other available means shall be used to inform those affected.
E. Enforcement.
Upon finding that there is probable cause to believe that any individual or individuals who are subject to an order of quarantine may fail or refuse to comply with such order, the commissioner in his sole discretion may include in the order a requirement that such individual or individuals are to be taken immediately into custody by law-enforcement agencies and detained for the duration of the order of quarantine or until the commissioner determines that the risk of and from noncompliance is no longer present.
For any individual or individuals identified as, or for whom probable cause exists that he may be, in violation of any order of quarantine, or for whom probable cause exists that he may fail or refuse to comply with any such order, the enforcement authority directed by the commissioner to law-enforcement agencies shall include but need not be limited to the power to detain or arrest.
Any individual or individuals so detained shall be held in the least restrictive environment that can provide any required health care or other services for such individual.
The commissioner shall ensure that law-enforcement personnel responsible for enforcing an order or orders of quarantine are informed of appropriate measures to take to protect themselves from contracting the disease of public health threat.
F. Health status monitoring.
The local health department shall monitor the health of those under quarantine either by regular telephone calls, visits, self-reports, or by reports of caregivers or healthcare providers or by other means.
If an individual or individuals develop symptoms compatible with the communicable disease of public health threat, then 12VAC5-90-103 would apply to the individual or individuals.
G. Essential needs.
Upon issuance of an order of quarantine to an individual or individuals by the commissioner, the local health department shall manage the quarantine, in conjunction with local emergency management resources, such that individual essential needs can be met to the extent practicable.
Upon issuance of an order of quarantine by the commissioner for an affected area, existing emergency protocols pursuant to Chapter 3.2 (§ 44-146.13 et seq.) of Title 44 of the Code of Virginia shall be utilized for mobilizing appropriate resources to ensure essential needs are met.
H. Appeals.
Any individual or individuals subject to an order of quarantine or a court-ordered confirmation or extension of any such order may file an appeal of the order of quarantine in accordance with the provisions of § 32.1-48.10 of the Code of Virginia.
An appeal shall not stay any order of quarantine.
I. Release from quarantine.
Once the commissioner determines that an individual or individuals are no longer at risk of becoming infected and pose no risk of transmitting the communicable disease of public health threat to other individuals, the order of quarantine has expired, or the order of quarantine has been vacated by the court, the individuals under the order of quarantine shall be released immediately.
If the risk of an individual becoming infected and transmitting the communicable disease of public health threat to other individuals continues to exist, an order of quarantine may be developed to extend the restriction prior to release from quarantine.
J. Affected area.
If the criteria in subsection A of this section are met and an area is known or suspected to have been affected, then the commissioner shall notify the Governor of the situation and the need to order quarantine for the affected area.
In order for an affected area to be quarantined, the Governor must declare a state of emergency for the affected area.
If an order of quarantine is issued for an affected area, the commissioner shall cause the order of quarantine to be communicated to the individuals residing or located in the affected area.
The use of multiple forms of communication, including but not limited to radio, television, Internet, and/or other available means, may be required in order to reach the individuals who were in the affected area during the known or suspected time of exposure.
The provisions for documentation, means of quarantine, enforcement, health status monitoring, essential needs, and release from quarantine described above will apply to the quarantine of affected areas.
Appropriate management of a disease of public health threat for an affected area may require the coordinated use of local, regional, state, and national resources.
In specifying one or more affected areas to be placed under quarantine, the objective will be to protect as many people as possible using the least restrictive means.
As a result, defining the precise boundaries and time frame of the exposure may not be possible, or may change as additional information becomes available.
When this occurs, the commissioner shall ensure that the description of the affected area is in congruence with the Governor’s declaration of emergency and shall ensure that the latest information is communicated to those in or exposed to the affected area.
Statutory Authority
§ 32.1-35 of the Code of Virginia.
Paul Plante says
In all truth, I always feel very silly making reference to laws and rules and regulations in here, as if they really existed in the real world, where they don’t, despite being written on paper for all to be able to read, starting with the governor of Virginia, and the health commissioner of Virginia, but anyway, pretending the law really is still the law, if you go back to 12VAC5-90-107. Quarantine above, in section C. Means of quarantine, you see these following words:
The local health department shall assess the situation, and in consultation with the Office of Epidemiology, shall recommend to the commissioner the least restrictive means of quarantine that effectively protects unexposed and susceptible individuals.
end quotes
Is locking down everyone really the least restrictive means of quarantine that effectively protects unexposed and susceptible individuals?
If so, what could possibly be more restrictive?
And then scroll down to J. Affected area, where it states as follows, to wit:.
If the criteria in subsection A of this section are met and an area is known or suspected to have been affected, then the commissioner shall notify the Governor of the situation and the need to order quarantine for the affected area.
end quotes
Does anyone know if that was ever actually done?
Did the commissioner ever notify Ralph Northam of the need to lock down the entire Commonwealth of Virginia?
In his EXECUTIVE ORDER NUMBER FIFTY-FIVE (2020) TEMPORARY STAY AT HOME ORDER DUE TO NOVEL CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19), governor Northam states and declares thusly, to wit:
To reinforce the Commonwealth’s response to COVID-19 and in furtherance of Executive Orders 51 (March 12, 2020) and 53 (March 23, 2020) and by virtue of the authority vested in me by Article V, Section 7 of the Constitution of Virginia, by § 44-146.17 of the Code of Virginia, I order the following:
1. All individuals in Virginia shall remain at their place of residence, except as provided below by this Order and Executive Order 53.
end quotes
But what authority is vested in Ralph Northam by Article V, Section 7 of the Constitution of Virginia?
Let’s take a look:
Article V. Executive
Section 7. Executive and administrative powers
The Governor shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed.
The Governor shall be commander-in-chief of the armed forces of the Commonwealth and shall have power to embody such forces to repel invasion, suppress insurrection, and enforce the execution of the laws.
end quotes
If the governor shall take care that the laws of the Commonwealth of Virginia be faithfully executed, would or should that include 12VAC5-90-107. Quarantine?
And what about § 44-146.17 of the Code of Virginia, where Title 44 is entitled Military and Emergency Laws and Chapter 3.2, where § 44-146.17 is found, is entitled Emergency Services and Disaster Law?
§ 44-146.17. Powers and duties of Governor, states:
The Governor shall be Director of Emergency Management.
He shall take such action from time to time as is necessary for the adequate promotion and coordination of state and local emergency services activities relating to the safety and welfare of the Commonwealth in time of disasters.
end quotes
Is COVID really a disaster pursuant to that section of law?
Or is that a reach (unlawful and unconstitutional power grab) on the part of Ralph Northam?
For that answer, let us go to § 44-146.14 of Chapter 3.2 of Title 44 of the Code of Virginia where we find thusly stated, to wit:
§ 44-146.14 Findings of General Assembly.
(a) Because of the ever present possibility of the occurrence of disasters of unprecedented size and destructiveness resulting from enemy attack, sabotage or other hostile action, resource shortage, or from fire, flood, earthquake, or other natural causes, and in order to insure that preparations of the Commonwealth and its political subdivisions will be adequate to deal with such emergencies, and generally to provide for the common defense and to protect the public peace, health, and safety, and to preserve the lives and property and economic well-being of the people of the Commonwealth, it is hereby found and declared to be necessary and to be the purpose of this chapter:
(1) To create a State Department of Emergency Management, and to authorize the creation of local organizations for emergency management in the political subdivisions of the Commonwealth;
(2) To confer upon the Governor and upon the executive heads or governing bodies of the political subdivisions of the Commonwealth emergency powers provided herein; and
(3) To provide for rendering of mutual aid among the political subdivisions of the Commonwealth and with other states and to cooperate with the federal government with respect to the carrying out of emergency service functions.
(b) It is further declared to be the purpose of this chapter and the policy of the Commonwealth that all emergency service functions of the Commonwealth be coordinated to the maximum extent possible with the comparable functions of the federal government, other states, and private agencies of every type, and that the Governor shall be empowered to provide for enforcement by the Commonwealth of national emergency services programs, to the end that the most effective preparation and use may be made of the nation’s resources and facilities for dealing with any disaster that may occur.
end quotes
Is locking down the entire Commonwealth of Virginia, because Ralph Northam considers COVID to be a disaster of unprecedented size and destructiveness, really an adequate measure to deal with COVID, assuming you could even call COVID a disaster, at all, which is a stretch given that most people will suffer mild symptoms from it, so as to provide for the common defense and to protect the public peace, health, and safety, and to preserve the lives and property and economic well-being of the people of the Commonwealth?
Is destroying the economic well-being of the people of the Commonwealth truly the best and only way of protecting the public peace, health, and safety, and preserving the lives and property of the people of the Commonwealth?
Seems a strange way to do it, to me!