January 16, 2025

2 thoughts on “Should New Northampton County School Complex be Carbon Neutral?

  1. As the Northampton County Board of Supervisors begins the process of conceptualizing a new School complex, I have several recommendations.

    1. Analyze both the costs and the tangible and intangible benefits of conforming to arbitrary constraints such as carbon-neutral, low carbon or other frameworks. In other words, how much more money will it cost to build a “carbon-neutral” or “low carbon” versus a conventional building with current technology to reduce energy and water consumption?

    2. Include a projection of operating costs for a 25 year period to gain a real understanding of the tangible benefits. In other words, practice good stewardship of these assets and analyze the tangible costs just like you would if you were paying the bill yourself (because you are!)

    3. Quantify the intangible benefits of incorporating “carbon-neutral” or “low carbon” technologies. In other words, if you think that a building with these attributes will make a measurable difference – prove it! Find a county in the U.S. that built a new school with these technologies and find out what the tangible, measurable benefits are. Finally, please don’t allow our supervisors to believe that there’s some kind of virtue or benefit to being “first” in applying some technology. History has shown that the “first in” for new technology seldom returns the expected benefit – why? Because there’s always risk in being the “early-adopter” of technology – and these risks always translate into cost to the owner (the taxpayer).

    Finally, Supervisor Bennett, both I and the Board of Supervisor need the data – the studies, data and actual experiences of counties where a carbon-neutral school building and a curriculum that has a focus on environmental sustainability has actually “driven economic revitalization.” I don’t believe that it’s that simple to raise the economic fortunes of the Eastern Shore.

    “…that new and modern schools are necessary to attract young families to move and invest here, to increase learning opportunities, and to be the driver and cornerstone of an economic revitalization.” (quote by Supervisor Bennett)

    Note: To clarify, Supervisor Bennett is only talking about the benefits that a new, modern complex would bring to the county in general. The Cape Charles Mirror is promoting a carbon neutral building. Also, the concept of carbon neutral in not new, see: South Fremantle School

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *