Supervisors have the final say on a zoning change officials pitched as a way to create more affordable housing
EASTVILLE — The Northampton County Planning Commission voted 4-2 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, against recommending a zoning text amendment to the Board of Supervisors. The amendment would allow greater housing density in the county’s town edge zoning districts, which officials have said would help create affordable housing.
Commissioner Charles Kolakowski, a former county administrator and the mayor-elect of Cheriton, made the motion to deny. Commissioners Patrick Rader, Stephanie Castro Webber and J. Tom Weaver joined him. Chairwoman Janet Sturgis and Commissioner J.T. Holland voted to recommend approval.
The commission’s vote is only a recommendation. The Board of Supervisors makes the final decision, and it was not immediately known when the board will take up the measure.
Opponents said the towns had not been consulted, that more development would threaten groundwater, and that it would strain county services.
Cape Charles Vice Mayor Andy Buchholz repeated his town’s support for the town edge changes.
Town edge districts are the zones just outside the county’s incorporated towns. The county has described them as the right place for compact, higher-density housing because they sit near existing services. When supervisors sent an earlier version to the Planning Commission in September 2025, they described it as modernizing and simplifying the “Town Edge” districts while encouraging compact, higher-density residential development near existing towns. Under that draft, lots could be as small as 10,000 square feet where central water and sewer are available. Lots with limited services would need 15,000 to 20,000 square feet, and supervisors later agreed to drop the central water requirement because no land under county jurisdiction has central water or sewer. Cluster developments, which group homes on smaller lots, would have to keep at least 40 percent of the tract as open space.
The lack of public water and sewer outside the towns is the basis for the groundwater objection. Homes built at higher density would rely on wells and septic systems. Former board chairman John Coker argued at the time that residential water use doesn’t strain aquifers, and he noted that the Health Department has approved quarter-acre lots with wells and septic systems.
The debate has gone on for more than a year. Before a June hearing, Supervisor Jon Dempster argued the change would create more housing, especially for young residents who can’t afford to stay, and noted that most of the county is zoned agricultural or conservation. On the other side, county resident Ken Dufty argued that the public and the affected towns had not been adequately informed, cited the comprehensive plan’s call for town involvement, and raised concerns about higher taxes and strain on county services. Some residents also feared the new districts would resemble planned unit developments, which they believe lean toward retirement communities rather than workforce housing.
Is density the threat, or is it the population trend?
People across Northampton County say housing is too expensive for young families and local workers. But density proposals keep drawing heavy opposition, and opponents often point to Cape Charles as the kind of growth they don’t want.
Census data shows Cape Charles is a special case, driven mainly by retirees and second-home buyers. The town has 1,201 residents with a median age of 60.5. Its median home value is $640,600, more than double the national median of $303,400. About 42.3% of its housing units are counted as vacant, a Census category that includes seasonal and vacation homes. Many buyers there are retirees who built wealth over their careers and want to spend their golden years in a small, quiet, and charming village, or people buying a vacation home to rent out now and move into when they retire. If that trend holds, the town will eventually have more wealthy full-timers, and the tourist seasons may become less horrific.
Meanwhile, the county as a whole is shrinking and getting older. The Census Bureau estimates Northampton’s 2025 population at 11,879, a 1.2% decrease. The county had 13,093 residents in 2000, so it has lost about 9% of its population since then. About 32% of residents are 65 or older.
With fewer residents each year, very few young families moving in, and little to no large-scale business growth, it’s fair to ask whether modest extra density at the edges of towns is the threat opponents say it is, or whether the real risk is a county without the housing to keep what’s left of its workforce, or the industrial base to fuel any real growth.

Right on Blue Hoss
Damn shame that you people have messed The Eastern Shore up so badly that you want to provide 'workforce housing'.…
Now, speaking of the present as you say, Peter, because what is past is gone and what is future is…
The Bible is full of stories of people just like that, so it seems an enduring human trait.
Incumbent Mayor Adam Charney, the Mayor of Cape Charles, Virginia who bills himself to the world at large as "The…