The war between Russia and Ukraine, with the White House continuing to reject any talk of a ceasefire, is at a turning point, writes Seymour Hersh.
There are significant elements in the American intelligence community, relying on field reports and technical intelligence, who believe that the demoralized Ukraine army has given up on the possibility of overcoming the heavily mined three-tier Russian defense lines and taking the war to Crimea and the four oblasts seized and annexed by Russia.
The reality is that Volodymyr Zelensky’s battered army no longer has any chance of a victory.
The war continues, according to Hersh, an official with access to current intelligence, because Zelensky insists that it must. There is no discussion in his headquarters or in the Biden White House of a ceasefire and no interest in talks that could lead to an end to the slaughter. “It’s all lies,” the official said, speaking of the Ukrainian claims of incremental progress in the offensive that has suffered staggering losses, while gaining ground in a few scattered areas that the Ukrainian military measures in meters per week.
“There were some early Ukrainian penetrations in the opening days of the June offensive,” the official said, “at or near” the heavily trapped first of Russia’s three formidable concrete barriers of defense, “and the Russians retreated to sucker them in. And they all got killed.” After weeks of high casualties and little progress, along with horrific losses to tanks and armored vehicles, he said, major elements of the Ukrainian army, without declaring so, virtually canceled the offensive. The two villages that the Ukrainian army recently claimed as captured “are so tiny that they couldn’t fit between two Burma-Shave signs” — referring to billboards that seemed to be on every American highway after World War II.
Zelensky’s message this week to the annual United Nations General Assembly in New York offered little new and, the Washington Post reported, he received the obligatory “warm welcome” from those in attendance. But, the Post noted, “he delivered his address to a half-full house, with many delegations declining to appear and listen to what he had to say.” Leaders of some developing nations, the report added, were “frustrated” that the multiple billions being spent without serious accountability by the Biden administration to finance the Ukraine war was diminishing support for their own struggles to deal with “a warming world, confronting poverty and ensuring a more secure life for their citizens.”
President Biden, in his earlier speech to the General Assembly, did not deal with Ukraine’s perilous position in the war with Russia but renewed his resounding support for Ukraine.
Biden, with the support of Secretary Blinken and National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan — but diminishing support elsewhere in America — has turned his unrelenting financial and moral support for the Ukraine war into a do-or-die issue for his re-election.
The American intelligence official noted here spent the early years of his career working against Soviet aggression and spying and has respect for Putin’s intellect but contempt for his decision to go to war with Ukraine and to initiate the death and destruction that war brings, “The war is over. Russia has won”. There is no Ukrainian offensive anymore, but the White House and the American media have to keep the lie going. The truth is if the Ukrainian army is ordered to continue the offensive, the army would mutiny. The soldiers aren’t willing to die anymore, but this doesn’t fit the B.S. that is being authored by the Biden White House,” Seymour Hersh concludes.
Paul Plante says
The Biden white house is nothing but BULL**** flowing in a continuous stream, while stinking to high heaven!
R. Meyers says
I think Mr Hersh has aged significantly since his MyLai reporting days and his analytic and corroborative capabilities seem to be failing. Before swallowing the Hersh Hash, for a more complete background, I suggest reading the following analysis by ISW. It is long, but well worth the read:
https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/weakness-lethal-why-putin-invaded-ukraine-and-how-war-must-end
Paul Plante says
The Ukrainians will rue the day they ever got in bed with Joe Biden and his crowd of idiots, morons, lackwits and fools:
Reuters
“White House has been in touch with allies over potential delays in new Ukraine funding”
October 2, 2023
WASHINGTON, Oct 2 (Reuters) – The White House has been in touch with allies and partners about continued funding for Ukraine and those conversations will continue, White House spokesperson Karine Jean-Pierre said on Monday.
Congress passed a stopgap bill on Saturday that extended government funding for more than a month and avoided a government shutdown but didn’t contain any new aid for Ukraine.
****************************************
And as to who they chose as their bed partners, the Ukrainians should have studied US history better before going to war based on any US promises of support, especially from Joe Biden, Tony Blinken, Jake Sullivan and the Democrats:
In 1974 (Vietnamese) President Thieu sent General Cao Van Vien to Washington to make the case for continued U.S. aid to South Vietnam.
At the Pentagon, where Vien briefed on the current military situation, complete with photographic evidence of mounting enemy violations and massive movement into South Vietnam, he was assured of full support.
On 6 May 1974 a legislative amendment proposed by Senator Edward Kennedy – one of those members of Congress most determined to pull the plug on South Vietnam – was accepted.
It cut $266 million for South Vietnam from a supplementary military aid bill and signified, suggested (Sir Robert) Thompson, “that perhaps the major lesson of the Vietnam war is: do not rely on the United States as an ally.”
– pp.366,367, A BETTER WAR, The Unexamined Victories and Final Tragedy of America’s Last Years in Vietnam by Lewis Sorley
Paul Plante says
And before they got into bed with Biden, Blinken and witless Jake Sullivan, in addition to checking them out for social diseases and bedbugs and crab lice, the Ukrainians really should have asked that trio of morons if at any prior time in their lives, had any of them ever successfully prosecuted a winning war strategy.
Paul Plante says
Before they got into bed with this trio of losers known as Biden, Blinken and witless Jake Sullivan, the Ukrainians should have taken a real hard look at just how many other countries this same pack of fools, in conjunction with Hussein Obama and Hillary “The Mouth That Roared” Clinton, totally ****** up and turned into lawless wastelands, like Libya, Iraq and Syria, and now Ukraine.