The Eastern Shore is now Virginia’s largest market for second homes. That did not happen by accident. It follows years of work, from the late 1990s through the mid-2000s, to bring more tourist dollars to the peninsula.
Accomack County has 5,207 second homes, and Northampton County has 1,081, according to a national real estate website. Accomack has more second homes than any other locality in Virginia. That includes Virginia Beach and the state’s popular lakefront counties.
Northampton’s total is smaller, but the county stands out in a different way. For its size, it has a disproportionately large number of second homes compared with its population.
From the late 1990s to the mid-2000s, local leaders and tourism promoters set out to draw visitors to the Shore. The advertising showed off what residents already knew: quiet beaches, open water, small towns and a slower pace of life.
It also showed something else. Compared with much of the East Coast, this coastal community was affordable.
That message reached people who had spent a lifetime working and building wealth. Many were nearing retirement and looking for a beautiful place where their money would go further. Some came as tourists. Many came back as buyers.
Cape Charles shows how the change unfolded. In the 1990s, many of the town’s homes were run-down and dilapidated. Some buyers bought them on credit cards.
Those buyers then restored and renovated the houses. Much of the Cape Charles that residents and visitors see today is the result of that work–the quaint and gorgeous historic district with its bustling downtown with its shops and eateries, as well as the high-end resort lifestyle of Bay Creek.
As buyers with money restored older homes and built larger luxury models, values went up. When values rise, assessments follow, and so do property tax bills for everyone, including families who have lived here for generations.
In Northampton, the median list price is now about $540,000, according to Zillow. That is well above Zillow’s typical home value for the county, about $312,000, which shows how far asking prices have pulled away from what many local homes are worth.
Those costs are now at the center of a debate over growth in Northampton. A proposed zoning amendment would let owners of land zoned Town Edge (TE-1) apply to rezone it as Town Edge Residential (TE-R). That would allow higher density and more housing meant to be (supposedly) more affordable.
Supporters of higher density and more housing argue that some of the people most opposed to growth arrived on the Shore themselves in recent decades. In their view, those residents want to keep the Shore’s beauty for themselves and close the door behind them, shutting out others who may want to live or invest here.
Editor’s Note: It seems ironic that groups like the Citizens for a Better Eastern Shore, a group that opposes things such as TE-1 and short-term rentals, are led by the early leaders of the Eastern Shore of Virginia Tourism Commission. CBES President Donna Bozza led the commission for seven years as its first tourism director/executive director. During her tenure, the region saw the highest percentage increase in tourism revenue in Virginia, growth that helped create today’s market. This writer was mocked for warning that building a robust tourism economy would have unintended consequences. Even dumb, stoned, moronic Virginia Beach surfers like me knew that…we witnessed firsthand.
The rise in second homes is the expected result of selling the Shore to the outside world. When a place markets its beauty and low cost, people with savings will come. Some will stay part of the year, and some will stay for good.
Turning back the clock would be hard. The homes have been bought, the towns have been rebuilt, and the Shore is now known well beyond the region. Scare tactics such as too many people will drain the sole source aquifer (without providing any serious, granular geological data) will not dissuade many from wanting to move or invest here.
For Cape Charles especially, a return to nostalgic memories is not likely.

Right on Blue Hoss
Damn shame that you people have messed The Eastern Shore up so badly that you want to provide 'workforce housing'.…
Now, speaking of the present as you say, Peter, because what is past is gone and what is future is…
The Bible is full of stories of people just like that, so it seems an enduring human trait.
Incumbent Mayor Adam Charney, the Mayor of Cape Charles, Virginia who bills himself to the world at large as "The…