October 14, 2025

25 thoughts on “Black Dog: My Life with Depression

  1. Speaking from many long years of experience with the subject as a disabled Viet Nam war veteran, I would say that when you are depressed, that indeed IS the way things are, regardless of whether or not they could or should be something else in the opinion of the outside observer.

    It’s a downward spiral many never escape from, which I have also had experience with in connection with other Viet Nam veterans, and non-veterans, as well.

    Pretty depressing, when you think about it.

    So if someone has escaped, and I don’t mean by going through life blotto on booze or drugs, which path many seem to choose, or maybe it chooses them, who can ever know, more power to them and those who were there to help and guide them.

  2. Turn, Turn, Turn to everything there is a season (The Byrds). Now is the time to grieve a life cut short by pain.
    Thanks for a poignant reflection.

  3. Thank you for posting this! I struggle everyday with the obstacles of PTSD and regaining mental healthiness.

    1. So do many in America, Kentoya Garcia.

      As one so afflicted, I know well the struggle you describe.

      And the road to recovery requires finding a sense of purpose that is yours, or so has been my experience of it.

      Those without a personal sense of purpose in my experience have not been able to climb out, because to take your mind off of something, you need something stronger to place it on.

          1. Todd Holden, I must admit that I find myself curious as to where your line of questioning of
            Kentoya Garcia, who @ August 4, 2019 at 12:21 pm posted, “I struggle everyday with the obstacles of PTSD and regaining mental healthiness,” and @ August 5, 2019 at 11:24 pm responded, “I was in an air assaulting accident when I was stationed in the Army,” is going.

            What I am curious about is what the location where the accident took place might have to do with Kentoya admitting in here to struggling everyday with the obstacles of PTSD and regaining mental healthiness.

            What I can’t understand is why would location matter at this point.

            Isn’t it more important to give Kentoya some encouragement, regardless of where the accident happened, that there is another side – that one can traverse the “lonesome valley” and emerge on the other side as a whole person?

            As to location, I have a friend who was an Army ranger in Big Bush’s Iraq War, and he was hurt in an air assaulting accident over here when the Chinook he was riding in crashed through some tree tops on the way to the ground.

            He still suffers memories of the tree branches crashing though the floor and the hard landing that followed when he is in pain.

            Should it be different because he was injured here, instead of in Iraq?

      1. To its credit, the VA now has something called the VA Whole Health System for veterans afflicted with PTSD, which has become little more than a label in our times that can and does apply to everything under the sun, seemingly including bad potty training which apparently can leave somebody badly psychologically scarred for the rest of their lives.

        It advertises itself as supporting physical, mental, emotional, spiritual, and environmental elements that work together to provide the best quality of life for Veterans, as opposed to dosing us up on a bunch of pills and meds that don’t do ****-all for the PTSD symptoms which include intrusive thoughts and concentration difficulties,.

        For improving attention, alertness, and information processing, one of the VA programs I would recommend to get one started with improved focusing ability is called bio-feedback.

        The VA is also beginning to have programs in t’ai Chi and yoga, and there are many studies available on-line concerning the efficacy of t’ai chi in helping one deal with the symptoms of PTSD, which are very real to the person afflicted, even if they cannot be understood by the casual observer not so afflicted.

        1. From: Women in the Military Flirting with Disaster by Brian Mitchell Regnery 1997

          The average female army recruit is 4.8 inches shorter, 31.7 pounds lighter, has 37.4 less pounds of muscle, and 5.7 more pounds of fat than the average male recruit.
          She has only 55% of the upper body strength and 72% of the lower body strength of the average male.

          She is also at a significant disadvantage when performing aerobic activities such as marching with heavy loads and working in the heat, since fat mass is inversely related to aerobic capacity and heat tolerance.
          Her lighter frame makes her more likely to suffer injuries due to physical exertion.

          An Army study of 124 men and 186 women in 1988 found that women are more likely to suffer leg injuries and nearly five times as likely to suffer fractures as men.
          Women, are consequently, less available for duty.
          There is without doubt a significant gap between the physical abilities of men and women.

          Nothing has done more to cheapen rank and diminish respect for authority than cute little female lieutenants and privates. … The presence of women inhibits male bonding, corrupts allegiance to the hierarchy, and diminishes the desire of men to compete for anything but the attentions of women. Pushing women into the military academies made a mockery of the academies’ essential nature and most honoured values.

          1. That reminds me of a recent CNN article entitled “Top US Navy SEAL tells commanders in light of misconduct: ‘We have a problem'” by Barbara Starr, CNN Pentagon Correspondent on 2 August 2019, as follows:

            Gen. David Berger, the new Marine Corps. commandant, said he was “troubled by the extent to which drug abuse is a characteristic of new recruits and the fact that the vast majority of recruits require drug waivers for enlistment.”

            He also said over the last ten years more than 25,000 Marines were dismissed from the service for misconduct, and drug and alcohol offenses.

            end quotes

            The times, they are not a’changing, Todd Holden, they have changed, and markedly so.

            But I remain unsure as to how that new reality concerns Kentoya Garcia and the very poorly understood subject of PTSD, which is a bundle of symptoms given a fancy name.

            Making it into an argument that women shouldn’t serve in the military is a distraction.

            Maybe if America’s younger generation of males wasn’t so hooked on drugs that they need drug waivers to become Marines, itself a mockery of what the Marines used to be, there wouldn’t be a need for women to pick up the slack, if you know what I am saying.

        2. If training and the middle east gives them ptsd, what would they get if they found themselves in WWI or Nam for that matter?

          1. A good question, Todd Holden, and as was made quite clear in the war movie “Apocalypse Now,” VEET NAM fried the brains of a lot of Americans, especially those who grew up “protected,” or in a city, because it was simply too much reality for them.

            People had trouble coping with the fact that, yes, there were people “out there” who wanted to kill them, given that they were really nice people who meant no harm to anyone and were only there because they didn’t have an out like Bill Clinton or Chuck Schumer and got drafted instead.

            And a lot of those people whose brains got fried never saw combat, or even knew it was going on, as the ratio of support troops to grunts in the field was something like 12 or 15 to one in VEET NAM.

            So how do you predict something, Todd Holden, that will result from someone being cast or thrown into an entirely alien environment, which could certainly include participating in air assault training, which is outside the ken of the majority of Americans, and a training accident can cause physical, mental and emotional trauma that can become debilitating later on in life.

            And the way PTSD works, which is like a “DO LOOP” in your consciousness, where the same movie gets played over and over again, it would be likely that someone who suffered trauma of some sort in a training accident would end up with a big snarled and tangled ball of emotions in their head which would include why it was they enlisted in the first place, and many other unanswerable questions, as well, and the only escape from that tangled mess is to treat it as a Gordian Knot which can only be severed.

            To “heal” from any trauma, you need to sever your connection to it.

            Situations, like planets, have gravity, and it is that gravity that keeps people tethered to things in their past that were to them traumatic.

            So, you have to escape that gravity to escape the continuing effects of the trauma on your mind.

            To do that, you need resolve and discipline and belief in your self.

            That would be my message to Kentoya Garcia.

  4. This is beautifully written, both in the words and the message. Thank you to Wayne and to the Mirror for printing it.

  5. You aren’t alone. So many people are fighting the battle of untreated depression. ZRT labs makes a neurotransmitter test to help find the right medicine to match your deficiencies that cause depression and anxiety. You can purchase it on Amazon and take the results to your doctor.

  6. Wayne thank you for sharing and baring. I had a best friend who took her life when we were teens. It took me a long time to forgive myself and realize I could not help her.

  7. Thank you for sharing your story. Thankfully God & the “right” meds keep me on mostly an even keel. It is a very sad time & healing takes time but grieving is necessary to move on in our lives. I just want ALL to know that if ever they need to talk. I am a good listener.

  8. Thank you for sharing your life. It will help so many.
    Your writing talent is up there. Book?
    Hope Saecker

  9. I have always admired your writing ability, and your endless search, like me, for the perfect martini ( but 1 is a good limit). Today was your best, honest, candid and I agree with other comments, few people have avoided periods of depression. Most people can relate to your experience.

  10. Thank you for your transparency and openness about your journey. May your words bring comfort to those feeling guilty.

  11. Your article on the Black Dog is spot on. Thank you for sharing your story. Depression can be so very difficult for the sufferer of it and the people closest to him/her. I have lived with it for many years. While it waxes and wanes, it’s an ever present part of my life.

    My heart goes out to Shane’s family and friends.

  12. Not once in your diatribe did you ever mention ‘Self Control”.

    Was that not an option?

    Note: Never had much of either. Kind of overrated anyway.

  13. Thank you for sharing Wayne.

    I did not personally know either of the beautiful people that were lost recently, but have friends that were shaken with the grief the whole community felt.
    I too have struggled for a number of years in and out of “the valley”. In Jan of 18 I found myself in some trouble, my thought processes where scaring me enough that I reached out to several longtime friends, each checked on me and I must have fooled them enough they left me as they found me, alone. Only months before I had reconnected with a person I not only went to school with, but grew up in the same neighborhood, over 40 years of ” knowing” this person. When I reached out to them , they dropped everything and came to my aid. This person made sure I was packed, placed my 80 pound dog in the back of their car and drove me across the Bay to meet family and receive some medical evaluation.
    I was lucky, I reached out and found a lifetime hero in my eyes. My Prayer is for those left behind, the families and friends. For those in “the valley” to call someone. For those feeling guilty, was not your fault.
    Sadly the decision does not end the pain, it only transfers it.

    While it will always be a part of me, it has come full circle for me, Life is Good.

    Live, Love and Learn.

Leave a Reply to Hope Saecker Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *