October 4, 2025

7 thoughts on “Undercover Investigator Exposes the Reality of Animal Agriculture

  1. Scotiagirl is touched by your compassion for one of God’s creatures. Certainly they cannot all be rescued from the fate to which they were born but as one who has raised many animals “for the table ,” (she’d rather not say “for slaughter,” ) Scotiagirl does believe that we should strive to enhance the quality of life for even the most lowly of creatures in our care. Few animals are more precious to her than a newborn lamb and she has taken orphans into her home, found near frozen in the snow, warmed them in her kitchen, nourished them with colostrum taken from their deceased mothers, put diapers on them and raised the in her home until they become strong enough to rejoin the flock. All this so that, when it became their time, she would load them in her truck and bring them to be “processed,” a nice word, she supposes, for “butchered” . Why? Because they came into this world as food, and this is where food comes from. Too many people don’t seem to be able to make that connection. But, just because an animal will someday be on your dinner plate, Scotiagirl believes it is still entitled to receive the best care she can provide for it. Make no mistake, Scotiagirl is not an “activist” but rather a realist.

  2. Many thanks for this very moving article. I grew up on a dairy farm with adjunct chicken houses and can confirm first-hand everything written in the primary article. I agree with Scotiagirl and MJM generally, except that I know, first-hand, that it is possible, at least for me, to treat farm animals humanely and not to use or sell them as food. I have observed a vegetarian (which is much easier than a vegan) diet for more than 25 years and, at age 76, consider myself healthy and not wanting for any dietary supplements. Those who have read my few comments to earlier MIRROR articles can easily determine my political orientation–firmly on the populist Right. Finally, the damage to soil and acquifers resulting from the industrial poultry and meat business, in addition to the farming of soybeans and corn to feed these animals, is turning Shore counties in Md, Del, and Va into virtual animal processing dumps. In Somerset County, where I grew up, the agricultural topsoil layer is thinning progressively, and brackish water from the Bay tributaries is seeping into farmland whose acquifers are being drained One can project, 75 years from now, a depopulated county consisting largely of saline marsh, whereas at the beginning of the 20th century it was a prosperous agricultural fruit and vegetable exporter.

    1. Don, really appreciated your comments but, make no mistake about it, although Scotiagirl raised lamb, chickens, pigs, calves and beef primarily for food and related by- -products, she made quite a number of pets out of them along they way!

      1. Dear Scotiagirl, I make a point never to criticize meateaters. These types of holier-than-thou critics are almost always obnoxious leftists whom I can’t possibly relate to. I do have one question, though: how does a person feel about eating an animal that was a pet? Even if I ate meat, I couldn’t do it.

        1. Scotiagirl did not want to take up too much space here so she did not elaborate…but since you asked: in the case of a hand raised bottle lamb, what nearly always happened was it was not butchered but rather was kept or sold to someone to be a “bell” sheep (could either be a ewe or wether–neutered ram) and sometimes raised to teach children for 4H projects. Other times such an animal might be saved from slaughter because it would be used as breeding stock (for herd improvement, in the case of an exceptional specimen) Anyway, this type of animal is very useful to help anyone without a herding dog (and there are MANY such “backyard” shepherds) to gather the herd, move them from place to place, etc. so that they can be sheared, put in pens, receive medical attention and so forth. The “bell” sheep, because it was a pet, in not afraid of humans. I have had a couple of pet sheep that became very useful as companions to orphan foals and\or nervous race horses. Yes, I do eat animals but none that I remember raising as “pets”. The point of my original post in this segment was that I firmly believe all animals, whether raised for the table or any other purpose, should be fed, housed and cared for properly . Sounds like you and Scotiagirl can agree on that !

Leave a Reply to MJM Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *